Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Warranty Claims

I've had a number of cats come through the bike shop lately with various warranty claims. Some are legitimate (such as a new KHE tire's blown sidewall), while others are completely rider error. In this post I intend to discuss the purpose, scope, and effects of the warranty process...


A Little History

There was once a day when a manufacturing failure would lead to the rider swear off that particular company for life... or until they came out with some far too cool new part. At the same time, the quality of complementary that made its way into the BMX market was marginal. Tolerances were wide open, if specified at all; and materials were often very poor. What this did was leave an opening in the market for some quality.

Enter the high(er) quality manufacturers. Profile Racing began offering tight tolerance machined hubs; Primo introduced their cold forged Powerbite cranks (cold forging offers greater tolerance control than casting or hot forging along with good grain orientation in the outer limits of the structure). These components earned a reputation for being less likely to bend, break, or snap. But how could companies compete with high end, and high dollar, components?

In the late 1990's Odyssey took a turn from mediocre quality, fair variety components, toward a different business model. The idea was to introduce two concurrent and complimentary ideas to their product line: post weld heat treatment for their forks, and a no-questions-asked warranty.

41 Thermal, as they call their heat treatment regimen is designed not only to reduce the heat affected zone inherent in welded components, but also to make the component bend noticeably before breaking. From this, Odyssey forks developed a reputation for being extremely strong, while staying cost, and weight competitive. Even though there have been quite a number of bent components over the years, the easy, and fairly quick warranty process has reduced the amount of negative feedback on their components.

Today, it is quite common for riders to suggest purchasing Odyssey components because of their amazingly lenient warranty process (Nuno even offered to warranty my cracked Polycarbonate Twisted pedals!) Picking up on this, many other manufacturers have eased and streamlined their warranty systems. They have learned that supporting the rider, even to some immediate detriment, can have long term beneficial effects.


Purpose of the Warranty Process

You can ask around and I am sure you will get various responses to this question. My response is from the perspective of a shop manager, rider, and prospective manufacturer. The warranty process should be designed to induce a positive company image in the mind of the rider. What this means is that a component should not fail without due cause (i.e. riding hard will inevitably damage parts, especially when we get into lighter weight components). If a component fails due to manufacturing errors, it should most definitely be covered under warranty. A common example of this is a crack directly on a weld, which indicates contamination in the melt pool, and subsequent weld.

There is another purpose, as the Odyssey example shows: to increase customer base simply because of the streamlined warranty process. Although I do not list this as a primary reason for purchasing a particular component, it is certainly beneficial to the rider; even more so if they are on a budget.


When a claim goes too far

I had a cat come into the shop with corroded nipples on a machine built (pre-built) wheel. He claimed it was a warranty issue because he had never see that happen before. Perhaps unfortunately for him, I had. The corrosion was due to excessive sweating seeping onto the aluminum nipples. The electrolytes in sweat increase the rate of oxidation (and on some materials nitrogenation) of materials. Often these oxides are much more brittle than their parent materials, leading to sudden failure or cracking. The point is manufacturers have no way of knowing, nor a reasonable way of preventing all of the outlying conditions that may lead to failure.

So the next time a part fails on you, ask yourself a few questions:

* How did the component fail (break? bend? where? how much?)?
* What lead to the failure?
* Could it have been a manufacturing issue?

Of course you could send in the product in any case, but if they deny your claim, don't give them a bad wrap if they conclude that it is not a manufacturing issue. If they do deny and you feel it is unjust, post it up on line with the question of whether it is a manufacturing fault.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Cold Forging at Shimano

Primo Powerbites, and now Hollowbites are advertised as being manufactured using cold forging technology. Effectively, they are smashing a blank piece of metal into the shape they want. Cold forging offers the advantage of precise control over dimensions, no need for heat treating, and aligns the grains along the surface of the part, perpendicular for forging direction. Hot forging, on the other hand, works better at aligning all of the grains of the part (up to a certain thickness, based on material characteristics), but cannot control dimensions as well.

Here is an article on Cozy Beehive about the cold forging at shimano. You'll notice the following graph, which may explain why some of the newer forged sprockets (such as Eastern's Medusa Lite, and Stolen's Mood Ring) are forged from 6061. Kudos to Primo for using a stronger, albeit tougher material to work with:

[forgeability+al+alloys.bmp]

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Bottom Bracket and Crank Standards

Browsing around the Cozy Behive, I found and article on the evolution of bottom brackets and interfaces in road and MTN bikes. Unfortunately, no mention of BMX bottom brackets. Here is the BMX-U page on BB's.

BMX has gone through the same evolution (loose ball, cartridge, press fit); the only difference being that BMX adopted the cupped, press fit US bottom bracket. Since then, we have moved independent, albeit parallel to the development of road/mtn bottom brackets. We have arrived at something very similar to the BB30 standard:

BB30: 42mm ID 68mm width
MID: 41.275mm (1 5/8") ID, 68mm width


Advantages of BB30

BB30 uses a standard metric ID, which makes off-the shelf bearings available for up to a 30mm spindle. Though it should be noted that to fit a fair sized bearing to take the extra side loads our bikes encounter, it may be best to limit spindle size to 25 mm. Even so, 25mm is larger than our existing 22, and 19mm spindles. With this increase comes the prospect of high strength 7068 or 7075 Aluminum.

Using an existing standard accepted by the rest of the cycling industry opens up the BMX market to larger manufacturers, higher technologies, and respectively, BMX companies' customer base. Hopefully, expanding their market will help smaller operations survive. Profile has a similar situation with their 48 spline cranks and dirt jumpers.



Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Baby Steps: a Summary of KHE Freecoaster Changes

Over the past 5 years, KHE’s freecoaster system has taken over the niche market. This was not because their product is the best we can do, but it is better than other options that were available (see my post on radial vs. axial freecoaster systems). In this post we will look at how the KHE system has evolved in its lifespan.



In the beginning was the Geisha. It offered a stud system (EAS) that allowed easy changing between 3/8” and 14mm in three different materials. That’s right, when it first came out, there were aluminum, steel, and titanium studs. They even went so far as to have a hybrid aluminum/steel clutch in their flatland version. The major advantage of the KHE was it’s ball-spring resistor, and low weight (Poverty coasters had the same resistor with a roller thrust bearing behind the clutch. But the resistor was eventually welded into place and the hub was pretty heavy in comparison)


Quickly after their initial run, the aluminum and ti studs, as well as the hybrid clutch were discontinued. To most people, this didn’t matter as the studs would unscrew with the axle regardless of material. Many would have preferred to use a bolt-on system (female axle), but KHE used a 3/8-26 thread in the aluminum spindle, which is very difficult to find bolts for. Blue6 now sells a bolt-on conversion kit for the KHE EAS system with titanium bolts and aluminum collars.


Now I am not sure if this next change came before the 1-piece axle or after, but it was an improvement none the less. KHE replaced the brass ball retainers with steel. Again, most people were unaffected, but to KHE’s defense, it was an attempt to fix the issue of customers tapping their axles out the wrong way (to remove any KHE axle, tap the drive side). Unfortunately, some people, when they encounter resistance, just hit the axle harder. Thus, customers still damage the retainers, and must purchase a new axle to replace them. I was always a bit annoyed that they didn’t make the retainers themselves available for the customers who damage them.


The next change marks the inflection point; when all of a sudden KHE took over the market, expanding horizontally to prevent competition. They finally came out with a 1-piece steel axle just before releasing the Federal and Reverse freecoasters. Both hubs were the same, but with different hubshells, and marketed under different brands. They both featured steel-one piece axle, but at a 4 oz weight penalty.


At this point, the Odyssey Reloader was out of the market, and the Poverty was rumored to be on it’s last run. KHE looked to fill the niche. They introduced LHD versions of both the Federal and Reverse. In order to do so, they would have to replace the threaded engagement ring with a splined one (if you run a threaded hubshell with LHD driver and clutch, the engagement ring will unscrew). There have been some issues with the splined ring coming loose, either by initial fit or compression of the aluminum splines. If you have this issue, retaining compound or JB Weld on the splines will fix it.


Some customers had issues blowing out the drive-side hubshell bearing. KHE attempted to fix this by switching the 6905 deep groove bearing with a 7905 angular contact bearing. Although not yet confirmed, it is believed the 7905 they are using is a 15 degree contact angle. Even this modest change can make a difference to someone who persistently blows out their drive side bearing. Unfortunately, the bearing seat is too thin to allow it to be bored out to accept an angular contact roller bearing, which would eliminate the issue all together (see Rob Ridge’s modified Reloader).


The drive side hubshell bearing was small potatoes compared to the driver bearing issues inherent in axial coaster systems (especially those with smaller drivers, unsealed bearings, and 14mm axles). KHE’s first attempt to resolve this issue was in the switch to steel in their 1-piece axle. The hope was that steel would better resist deformation of the measly 0.5mm bearing shoulder on the axle. It didn’t work. Their next attempt was to install a thrust bushing behind the 6902 bearings in the driver. I do not know how this has affected the number of driver bearing issues, but can’t help see it as an attempt to again fix the symptom (blown bearings) rather than the problem (axial wheel loads on the driver bearings).


Their most recent attempt to fix the driver issue was to have a custom bearing made by reducing the inner diameter from 15mm to 14mm. This gives a 1.5mm shoulder as opposed to a 0.5mm one. Although I like that they are addressing the issue, custom bearings always create headaches (such as buying a new axle that won’t work with your existing bearings). And again, it is not a proper solution to the underlying problem.


And finally, the one I skipped: somewhere along the line, KHE made a modification to the 1-piece axle to allow external slack adjustment. This was the first coaster to do so. It uses a simple screw attached to the internal stop-washer. A nice improvement indeed, but I have felt no inclination to change my slack, once set to my preference, in any of the coasters I have ridden.




So what can you take out of all of this?

  • KHE has made incremental improvements in their design over the years. This extends the lifespan of the product line.
  • KHE has committed to their system by expanding horizontally, now having 5 production models as nearly 50% of coasters currently available (Astern, Geisha lt, Reverse, Federal, Alienation).
  • Pushing KHE to make specific improvements may actually manifest them. Though look for incremental change, as they will likely milk this system for as long as they can before releasing something new (I hope they are working on a radial system, since they are still the only company to have released one, even if it was a failure).

Friday, January 29, 2010

The History of the Lathe

Here is a very in-depth look at the history of the lathe. He does a good job of explaining what advancements were made, and how those affected the materials used and the quality of finished turnings.