Showing posts with label manufacturing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manufacturing. Show all posts

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Warranty Claims

I've had a number of cats come through the bike shop lately with various warranty claims. Some are legitimate (such as a new KHE tire's blown sidewall), while others are completely rider error. In this post I intend to discuss the purpose, scope, and effects of the warranty process...


A Little History

There was once a day when a manufacturing failure would lead to the rider swear off that particular company for life... or until they came out with some far too cool new part. At the same time, the quality of complementary that made its way into the BMX market was marginal. Tolerances were wide open, if specified at all; and materials were often very poor. What this did was leave an opening in the market for some quality.

Enter the high(er) quality manufacturers. Profile Racing began offering tight tolerance machined hubs; Primo introduced their cold forged Powerbite cranks (cold forging offers greater tolerance control than casting or hot forging along with good grain orientation in the outer limits of the structure). These components earned a reputation for being less likely to bend, break, or snap. But how could companies compete with high end, and high dollar, components?

In the late 1990's Odyssey took a turn from mediocre quality, fair variety components, toward a different business model. The idea was to introduce two concurrent and complimentary ideas to their product line: post weld heat treatment for their forks, and a no-questions-asked warranty.

41 Thermal, as they call their heat treatment regimen is designed not only to reduce the heat affected zone inherent in welded components, but also to make the component bend noticeably before breaking. From this, Odyssey forks developed a reputation for being extremely strong, while staying cost, and weight competitive. Even though there have been quite a number of bent components over the years, the easy, and fairly quick warranty process has reduced the amount of negative feedback on their components.

Today, it is quite common for riders to suggest purchasing Odyssey components because of their amazingly lenient warranty process (Nuno even offered to warranty my cracked Polycarbonate Twisted pedals!) Picking up on this, many other manufacturers have eased and streamlined their warranty systems. They have learned that supporting the rider, even to some immediate detriment, can have long term beneficial effects.


Purpose of the Warranty Process

You can ask around and I am sure you will get various responses to this question. My response is from the perspective of a shop manager, rider, and prospective manufacturer. The warranty process should be designed to induce a positive company image in the mind of the rider. What this means is that a component should not fail without due cause (i.e. riding hard will inevitably damage parts, especially when we get into lighter weight components). If a component fails due to manufacturing errors, it should most definitely be covered under warranty. A common example of this is a crack directly on a weld, which indicates contamination in the melt pool, and subsequent weld.

There is another purpose, as the Odyssey example shows: to increase customer base simply because of the streamlined warranty process. Although I do not list this as a primary reason for purchasing a particular component, it is certainly beneficial to the rider; even more so if they are on a budget.


When a claim goes too far

I had a cat come into the shop with corroded nipples on a machine built (pre-built) wheel. He claimed it was a warranty issue because he had never see that happen before. Perhaps unfortunately for him, I had. The corrosion was due to excessive sweating seeping onto the aluminum nipples. The electrolytes in sweat increase the rate of oxidation (and on some materials nitrogenation) of materials. Often these oxides are much more brittle than their parent materials, leading to sudden failure or cracking. The point is manufacturers have no way of knowing, nor a reasonable way of preventing all of the outlying conditions that may lead to failure.

So the next time a part fails on you, ask yourself a few questions:

* How did the component fail (break? bend? where? how much?)?
* What lead to the failure?
* Could it have been a manufacturing issue?

Of course you could send in the product in any case, but if they deny your claim, don't give them a bad wrap if they conclude that it is not a manufacturing issue. If they do deny and you feel it is unjust, post it up on line with the question of whether it is a manufacturing fault.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Cold Forging at Shimano

Primo Powerbites, and now Hollowbites are advertised as being manufactured using cold forging technology. Effectively, they are smashing a blank piece of metal into the shape they want. Cold forging offers the advantage of precise control over dimensions, no need for heat treating, and aligns the grains along the surface of the part, perpendicular for forging direction. Hot forging, on the other hand, works better at aligning all of the grains of the part (up to a certain thickness, based on material characteristics), but cannot control dimensions as well.

Here is an article on Cozy Beehive about the cold forging at shimano. You'll notice the following graph, which may explain why some of the newer forged sprockets (such as Eastern's Medusa Lite, and Stolen's Mood Ring) are forged from 6061. Kudos to Primo for using a stronger, albeit tougher material to work with:

[forgeability+al+alloys.bmp]

Monday, March 22, 2010

A closer look at detanglers (Gyros)

Although they have gone a bit out of fashion, I have always found detanglers to be an integral part of my brake setup for two reasons:
  1. I NEVER have to unwind my bars/cable(s)
  2. Properly setup, the load is distributed over two cables, rather than one. This leads to an increase in stiffness, as well as providing a failsafe in the event that one cable snaps.
On that note, I highly suggest the use of a dual cable setup (either with an Odyssey Modulever, or something like the Dragonfly/Snafu adapter) and brake noodles for the lower bends.


Note: No detangler manufacturer recommends disassembling their units, nor should it be necessary unless you lubricate a bushing detangler. But I find these things fun and throw caution to the wind :)


But this post is about the guts of detanglers, so lets get on to that. The original Gyro (or Oryg) is pretty easy to figure out: 2 pieces of stamped and bent steel with loose-ball bearings. These use no lubrication; actually, they require no lubrication be used. By doing so, debris is able to freely pass through the bearing mechanism without being trapped by lubricants.

Advantages:
  • Cheap and easy to manufacture
  • Replacements are available at almost all bicycle shops
Disadvantages:
  • Flexy
  • Can be noisy and not so smooth when debris is present
  • Prone to "gyro flop" where the detangler shifts side to side due to uneven cable lengths (which can be adjusted out, but is more difficult than newer detanglers)


Next came the Odyssey GTX sealed bearing detangler(s). The original steel has been discontinued due to much better sales of the lighter GTX-R aluminum version. Both are a good improvement on the above Gyro.

Advantages:
  • Sealed to keep things running smooth for a good long while
  • Very stiff assembly reduces the incidence of "gyro flop"
  • GTX-R (aluminum) is a good bit lighter and available in red and blue anodizing
  • Long lasting (I have never worn one out)
  • Built in set screws for custom cable setups
  • Can be disassembled with a flat head screw driver
Disadvantages:
  • Set screws tend to fray cables, deterring many people from using them
  • Virtually all cable heads require modification to not hit one another. The main culprit is the seats for the cables were machined shallow to allow for the set screws
  • Significantly more expensive than competition
  • Difficult to rebuild as balls do not easily hold in the retainer





A response to the GTX by Snafu, and more recently Stolen, is a simple Teflon bushing detangler called the Mobeus (or Satellite).

Advantages:
  • Cable heads sit snug and clear one another
  • Bushing requires no lubrication
  • Lower cost and weight than GTX (though the GTX-R is within 0.2 oz)
  • Low profile
Disadvantages:
  • When lubed, debris builds up quickly and rapidly degrades performance
  • Some people complain of binding when pulling the brakes during a tailwhip
  • More prone to "gyro flop" than the GTX, but less than Gyro/Oryg
  • Requires snap ring pliers to disassemble


Wednesday, March 10, 2010

An Issue (and Solution) with Investment Casting

I was flipping through the Industrial Design Guide that I posted up a few weeks ago, and came to the page about investment casting. When I read some issues with the casting process. Typically, when the metal is poured into the mold, there are some unindented inclusions like Oxygen, metals, or other containments. Also, the act of pouring the metal creates turbulence and may allow pores to form, leading to compromised product integrity.

A solution to this is the Hitchner Counter Pressure Process. Basically it is filling a mold from the bottom up: You use vacuum pressure to pull the molten metal into the mold at a controlled rate. By doing so, the metal flows freely, with significantly reduced turbulence, and a better finished product. Certainly, there is an initial investment cost for moving to this method. But as with all manufacturing, diligence in pursuing cost-effective advancements will lead to better competitiveness.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Swaging

I've noticed a lot of forks and frames using "swagged" and tapered tubes. But what exactly is swagging? Usually it is a colt working or forging operation to reshape a tube. Here is the Wikipedia link. And some videos: 1, 2, 3

Although the three videos here show increasing the tube size, it is used in BMX to reduce or reshape the tube.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Chain Tensioners

... Or wheel positioners. It really depends on your purpose for putting them on. You may want them to maintain a consistent chain tension, like my tail-whip fiending friend, so the pedals will stay in position when your feet leave them. Or perhaps your wheel moves on you when you don't have it slammed in the dropouts, but slammed, the chain is too loose. A positioner will allow you to give extra support to prevent the wheel from moving. This post will analyze the various types of possitioners available and weigh their pros and cons against one another.


Pull-Type
The original tensioner design consists of a washer around the axle, with either a stud and nut, or bolt. The bolt/nut tightens against a plate on the end of the dropout
Some pull-type tensioners have issues with shorter dropouts. But as of late, slimmed down designs (such as the Poverty Short Stop shown above) have almost done away with that problem.

A variation on the design is the Premium SS Tesnioner, which uses the bolt to push directly against the dropout. With the proper bolt size, this tensioner can work with any size dropout. Unfortunately with only a bolt in contact with the curved end of the dropout, it can move around pretty easily.


Push-type
These tensioners have appeared in recent years in two variations:

1. Integrated tensioners into the dropout use a set screw or bolt through the dropout to push the wheel back and into possition. The pressure on the axle threads may compact them slightly. This may cause some issues on hubs with threaded collars, and may allow the wheel to slip forward slightly as the threads compact. (ex: Sunday wave dropouts)



2. Bolt-on tensioners use a bolt-on tab similar to gyro tabs and cable guides. They push on the hub collar rather than the axle itself. In some cases there can be interference with the chain and/or driver. (ex: Fly Tierra)



Spacer type
In the past, riders have jammed various items between their axle and dropout to allow their wheel to be "slammed". I used aluminum cable ends crushed down and carefully inserted, but they would continue to compact, and were difficult to work with. Simple BMX has come out with specially cut spacers in 0.1mm variations. With the availability of half-links (albeit current designs are rather flawed in that they stretch easily), a wheel only needs up to 13mm of adjustment as the chain is 12.7mm pin-to-pin. Unfortunately there are reports of these compacting down (or more likely compacting into the threads of the axle)





Drive vs. Non-drive
With the chain on the drive side, tensioners only need to work in one direction (the chain works in the other). As such, tensioners have been designed to work only moving the wheel out of the dropouts. The problem arises when working with the non-drive side, especially with pegs. When a load is taken pushing the drive side axle out of the dropouts (such as an ice pick or tail tap), the tensioner does not support the wheel, and thus it can move out of position. To fix this problem, we may want to start looking into a hybrid push-pull tensioner. I have done some work integrating this into a hub collar and/or guard. I'll post up more info when I get some prototypes done...

Monday, March 1, 2010

Book Recommendations

I've been doing some reading as of late. Here are two of the books I found most useful:


Industrial Design by Jim Lesko

I picked this book up at the local library expecting the usual design crap: Furnature, cars, and hubless wheels. To my surprise, I found a well organized overview of manufacturing methods for a variety of materials. The book doesn't go too in depth into any particular subject, but it provides a nice introduction and reference for the aspiring product designer. More than just an easy read, Lesko includes many informative diagrams. These pictures are worth a thousand words; I highly recommend this to anyone getting into the field/hobby/whatever.




The Ice Cream Maker by Subir Chowdhury

I know what you are thinking, "what the hell does this have to do with BMX?" This short (115 pg.) book is the tale of an ice cream factory manager who develops his company into a more efficient, competitive, and quality-focused organization. The book focuses on how supporting your customers and community (that includes everyone from the employees, to the people who live around you), in order to create a healthier, more self-sufficient organization. For any of you in management, or looking to get into business for yourself, this is a required read :)

Monday, February 22, 2010

An open attempt to improve axial free coasters

A few members on BikeGuide have started discussing how to improve axial coasters. The idea is to come up with a design that can be easily made and will at least improve the issues faced with axial freecoasters. Here are some requirements (see the thread for more details):

  • Low cost (i.e. using as many existing components as possible)
  • Low(er) weight; sub 20 oz
  • Suitable for peg use, not necessarily abuse.
  • Better bearing system, especially in the driver
  • Easy, and safe maintenance (i.e. no little pieces to damage)

If you have suggestions, or would just like to participate in the process, please post your comments in the BG thread, or here and I will forward to the thread. Once we come up with something suitable, I will post the dimensions, CAD files, and any other info on BMX-U.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Director Patent and Construction

I was pleasantly surprised to find this in my Google Reader list this morning. If you don't know about Reader, it is a web based application for aggregating RSS feeds, updated search results, and other periodicals. The recommendation and searching functions are pretty good, but some of the BMX RSS feeds are surrounded by noise (i.e. one good feed with a bunch of dead ones).


Director Forks have interested me since they were first unveiled. Integrating the dropouts with the fork legs is a logical step that was taken by road and some mountain quite a while ago. Eliminating the weld at the dropout avoids cracks there as well. And using a simple insert gives good compression support, while maintaining a hollow dropout for weight. Overall a nice design. Unfortunately, since this is included in the patent, any other company who wishes to go the integrated dropout route will have to find a manufacturing method that does not violate George's patent.

The crown junction is another unique feature of the directors (unless you look at sunday's chainstay wishbone that G had a hand in as well). The claim is that it reduces localized stress and extra material found in conventional open ended steerers.

I'll dig into this deeper after some discussion, but I really have to head off to class, so this simple post is all that is going up for now :)



Some random feeds I subscribe to (post yours up!):

- Bicycle Design is not updated all that often, but can be interesting.

- Sweeter Skins for those of you with Android phones, this is really the future in UI.

- Roues Artisanales mostly posts in French about the road bike weight weenie scene.

- Cool Tools updates often with some neat little productivity tools.

- Scheier on Security is one of my favorite blogs. Written by a security expert who is often contacted to comment on security issues by media, government, and private agencies. He takes a very logical approach to dissecting issues. His post "Fear and Over-reaction" really struck a chord in me.

- Google Patent "Bicycle" Search feed updates every so often with new results (usually patent applications or updates). You can use Google patents to get customized results.

- Endless Innovation has some good posts, but can be a bit repetitive at times.

- Physics World has some neat, informative updates about research findings in classical, relativistic, and quantum physics.

- The Big Picture has great photography, and is updated very regularly. Each post contains a link to 40 high-def photos about a certain topic.

- F-Secure has regular, detailed computer security reports.

- Cycling Tech hasn't been updated in 2 months, but it has some cool stuff when they do.

- Industrial Design has a lot of design *cough* Crap *cough*, but you can find some real gems in there. Be weary of hub-less bicycles, there is a reason they haven't gone to production.

- Ted Talks are a great way to look at a situation from a particular (speaker's) perspective. They are all free videos on a very wide range of topics.

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Baby Steps: a Summary of KHE Freecoaster Changes

Over the past 5 years, KHE’s freecoaster system has taken over the niche market. This was not because their product is the best we can do, but it is better than other options that were available (see my post on radial vs. axial freecoaster systems). In this post we will look at how the KHE system has evolved in its lifespan.



In the beginning was the Geisha. It offered a stud system (EAS) that allowed easy changing between 3/8” and 14mm in three different materials. That’s right, when it first came out, there were aluminum, steel, and titanium studs. They even went so far as to have a hybrid aluminum/steel clutch in their flatland version. The major advantage of the KHE was it’s ball-spring resistor, and low weight (Poverty coasters had the same resistor with a roller thrust bearing behind the clutch. But the resistor was eventually welded into place and the hub was pretty heavy in comparison)


Quickly after their initial run, the aluminum and ti studs, as well as the hybrid clutch were discontinued. To most people, this didn’t matter as the studs would unscrew with the axle regardless of material. Many would have preferred to use a bolt-on system (female axle), but KHE used a 3/8-26 thread in the aluminum spindle, which is very difficult to find bolts for. Blue6 now sells a bolt-on conversion kit for the KHE EAS system with titanium bolts and aluminum collars.


Now I am not sure if this next change came before the 1-piece axle or after, but it was an improvement none the less. KHE replaced the brass ball retainers with steel. Again, most people were unaffected, but to KHE’s defense, it was an attempt to fix the issue of customers tapping their axles out the wrong way (to remove any KHE axle, tap the drive side). Unfortunately, some people, when they encounter resistance, just hit the axle harder. Thus, customers still damage the retainers, and must purchase a new axle to replace them. I was always a bit annoyed that they didn’t make the retainers themselves available for the customers who damage them.


The next change marks the inflection point; when all of a sudden KHE took over the market, expanding horizontally to prevent competition. They finally came out with a 1-piece steel axle just before releasing the Federal and Reverse freecoasters. Both hubs were the same, but with different hubshells, and marketed under different brands. They both featured steel-one piece axle, but at a 4 oz weight penalty.


At this point, the Odyssey Reloader was out of the market, and the Poverty was rumored to be on it’s last run. KHE looked to fill the niche. They introduced LHD versions of both the Federal and Reverse. In order to do so, they would have to replace the threaded engagement ring with a splined one (if you run a threaded hubshell with LHD driver and clutch, the engagement ring will unscrew). There have been some issues with the splined ring coming loose, either by initial fit or compression of the aluminum splines. If you have this issue, retaining compound or JB Weld on the splines will fix it.


Some customers had issues blowing out the drive-side hubshell bearing. KHE attempted to fix this by switching the 6905 deep groove bearing with a 7905 angular contact bearing. Although not yet confirmed, it is believed the 7905 they are using is a 15 degree contact angle. Even this modest change can make a difference to someone who persistently blows out their drive side bearing. Unfortunately, the bearing seat is too thin to allow it to be bored out to accept an angular contact roller bearing, which would eliminate the issue all together (see Rob Ridge’s modified Reloader).


The drive side hubshell bearing was small potatoes compared to the driver bearing issues inherent in axial coaster systems (especially those with smaller drivers, unsealed bearings, and 14mm axles). KHE’s first attempt to resolve this issue was in the switch to steel in their 1-piece axle. The hope was that steel would better resist deformation of the measly 0.5mm bearing shoulder on the axle. It didn’t work. Their next attempt was to install a thrust bushing behind the 6902 bearings in the driver. I do not know how this has affected the number of driver bearing issues, but can’t help see it as an attempt to again fix the symptom (blown bearings) rather than the problem (axial wheel loads on the driver bearings).


Their most recent attempt to fix the driver issue was to have a custom bearing made by reducing the inner diameter from 15mm to 14mm. This gives a 1.5mm shoulder as opposed to a 0.5mm one. Although I like that they are addressing the issue, custom bearings always create headaches (such as buying a new axle that won’t work with your existing bearings). And again, it is not a proper solution to the underlying problem.


And finally, the one I skipped: somewhere along the line, KHE made a modification to the 1-piece axle to allow external slack adjustment. This was the first coaster to do so. It uses a simple screw attached to the internal stop-washer. A nice improvement indeed, but I have felt no inclination to change my slack, once set to my preference, in any of the coasters I have ridden.




So what can you take out of all of this?

  • KHE has made incremental improvements in their design over the years. This extends the lifespan of the product line.
  • KHE has committed to their system by expanding horizontally, now having 5 production models as nearly 50% of coasters currently available (Astern, Geisha lt, Reverse, Federal, Alienation).
  • Pushing KHE to make specific improvements may actually manifest them. Though look for incremental change, as they will likely milk this system for as long as they can before releasing something new (I hope they are working on a radial system, since they are still the only company to have released one, even if it was a failure).

Friday, January 29, 2010

The History of the Lathe

Here is a very in-depth look at the history of the lathe. He does a good job of explaining what advancements were made, and how those affected the materials used and the quality of finished turnings.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Gun Drills

Gun Drills are used for deep bores. And are usually equipped with channels for feeding coolant from the base to the end of the drill. Using a normal drill would not work because the flutes are not long enough to evacuate chips and flood the cutting surface with coolant. Drills are available in straight or spiral flutes (spiral drills are made by taking a two flute straight drill, heating, and twisting).


Here is a link that talks about making air gun barrels. Kind of a good description.

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Sprocket/Crank Interface


In recent years we have seen a shift in sprocket/crank interface paradigm... Ok, that may be a bit exaggerated... At least there has been a change in design.


Traditional, Perpendicular Bolt

My first introduction to crank torque transfer was with the integrated stud on one piece cranks. Although effective, tolorances were often poor, and low-end sprockets were usually thin steel, further compounding any issues.


As BMX progressed, we moved to a bolt to secure the sprocket to the crankset (usually 3/8" or 10mm). Today, virtually all cranks use the bolt-on design. This helped solve some of the tolerance issues and has served as the standard for bmx. From a structural perspective, this design requires either a larger spindle boss or a separate hole cut in the crank arm for a sprocket boss.

A slight hybrid of one and three piece mounting systems, that has resurfaced recently is the use of a headless bolt. Mechanik makes a bolt called the Pin Head. The purpose of this design is not to hold the sprocket to the crank, but only to transfer torque. Using this design allows small spacers to be inserted between the arm and the sprocket to dial in the chainline.



Nano-drive

As Sprockets reduced in size (with flatland at the forefront), a need for less offset in the mounting position. Enter the nano-drive. Most nano-drive bosses use smaller bolts than the standard bosses.



Spline Drive

When faced with the challenge of small sprockets, Tree Bicycle Co. decided to redesign the mounting design. What they came up with was transfering torque through the spindle, rather than the crank arm. With most cranks now using 19mm, 48 spline, Tree's spline drive has a large potential market. Recently Profile decided to release their own version of spline drive (releasing a spline drive sprocket was logical for Profile as they are known for their 48 spline cranks). Unfortunately, Profile decided it was best to use 8 large splines on the adapter, rather than the 9 available on the Tree. I don't know why this happened, but it may be just to avoid any patent issues.

There is one big problem with spline drive: it is limited to 19mm, 48 spline cranks.

Socket Drive/ Nonogram

Flatware's (Odyssey) response to shrinking sprockets was to standardize. Well, sort of. They are the only company making a crank that works with the 9-sided mating surface, but do provide the specs and drawings(PDF) on their site. If this design is adopted, adapters can be made to adapt socket drive to a 48-spline crank, in effect making it another spline drive. The big advantage to this over standard spline drive is it does not limit the spindle design.



Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Rim Materials

Just a reference of Rim Materials:



Density: 2.70 g/cc
Brinell Hardness: 95
Yield Tensile Strength: 276 MPa



Density: 2.72 g/cc
Brinell Hardness: 120
Yield Tensile Strength: 359MPa



Density: 2.78 g/cc
Brinell Hardness: 94
Yield Tensile Strength: 290 MPa



Density: 2.81 g/cc
Brinell Hardness: 150
Yield Tensile Strength: 503 MPa



Interesting results. I don't think 7075 is really used in extrusions, but I thought it was an interesting comparison. I first heard of 6066 when I looked at the Eclat Rims.

Monday, January 18, 2010

Handlebar-stems: An analysis

Ever since I saw the Cinelli Ram handle-stem, I have been fascinated with why we haven't moved to integrating in BMX. In this posting, I aim to to address the issues that come up in the upper steering system.


Note: a discussion on BikeGuide has pointed out two things: 1) I jump to the conclusion that forward/backward loads will not bend your bars without evidence; 2) The major challenge with 1-piece systems are their lack of adjustability both in reach (stem length) and bar angle (if, for some reason you don't want it in line...)


Vertical loads defined by loading both ends of the bar equally. In this case, the bends are stressed, and once the load exceeds the yield strength of the material, it will deform plastically (i.e. bend). During vertical loads, the stem is stressed vertically. Although longer stems will act as longer levers, when was the last time you bent a stem down?




Torsional Loads are typically qualified by loading of one side of the handlebar. These loads exhibit the traditional stress to the bends, but create a torsional load on the stem. A quick side note: torsional stiffness is proportional to stem body diameter, material choice, and thickness


Forward Loads are those times when you land a bit flat-bottom and find yourself shoving the handlebars forward. These loads are not characterized by large forces, but often end in the bars slipping in the stem. Promptly followed by a trip to the tool bag. Now some people claim that it is better the bar slips in this situation (or the opposite load where the front of the bars are loaded backward). The probability that either of these situations would end in plastic deformation is very small. Seeing as forward/backward loads are the only loads that can make the stem slip, and there is little chance of damaging the bars, I see little reason to not fix the bars to the stem.



So what do I propose? I would like to see more integrated bar-stems in the BMX market. As we get more market saturation, integrated bar-stems will be available in all the different geometries stems and handlebars come in. And let's face it, there are so few innovations in handlebars, the sector could use a bit more spice. We'll have to change our perspective on how these are clamped on the steerer tube, but that will spur innovation, and reduce overall weight.




Some examples...





Carbon Fiber Suspensions



There have been a few mountain and road bikes that use the inherently high fatigue strength of carbon fiber to design dampening systems into the frame. Looking through some of these designs, I found an interest in carbon fiber composites as suspension (or spring) systems.


Here is a patent about carbon fiber coil springs.


Clip in pedals with carbon fiber retaining springs:



















Many super-lite road brakes have been using composite springs for a while now. This is where I see some potential for BMX. We may be able to design a U-brake with a linear spring that will allow more design freedom.






































It would be interesting to read an analysis of the Histeresis involved in composite springs...

EDIT: Our rep left a Keo Blade pedal with the carbon spring, in the shop. It is very nice, and actually a cool manufacturing desing (i.e. those flat carbon springs must be significantly cheaper to produce than Ti coil springs)

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Bearing Specifications

Another great link. This one about the different designations given to bearings. It has helped me with bearing selection in some components.

EDIT: Wow, a long time later, I finally realize that I never posted the link. Sorry about that. The info its up at BMX-U now

Thursday, December 3, 2009

One Problem With Welding (HAZ)

What changed when Odyssey introduced 41 Thermal? Aside from finally focusing on the quality of their components, and backing them up with easy customer service, they started to heat treat their welded components after welding.

The issue with welding

Although there is extra material when you weld two components together, the biggest detriment is the Heat Affected Zone (HAZ). The area immediately around the weld becomes stiffer and less ductile. These properties lead to more propensity to crack. Take a look at cracks, and you'll find many of them occur around welds (cracks in welds are always a manufacturing defect, usually arising from voids in the weld).


Gussets

This is a problem that has plagued bicycles since we switched from lugged and brazed frames to welded. Gussets are one attempt at fixing it. The idea is that welding a plate effectively moves the HAZ farther down the tube, reducing the likely hood to crack. However, this adds a thick plate, and welds to the structure, leaving us with a heavier component. And let's face it, gussets are just not an elegant solution (take a look at the cool design/gusset below. Reminds me of lugged steel road frames).


Internal Gussets

Internal gussets are NOT gussets. They are a type of offset butting. Although a good idea (because it places material where it can most effectively support the loads encountered), these do not move the HAZ. You may be able to argue the added thickness slightly shrinks the HAZ, it does not significantly affect it.


Heat Treated Tubing

Tube manufacturers, like True Temper, Sanko, etc, will heat treat their tubesets after extrusion to optimize their mechanical properties. However, this heat treating is altered in the HAZ. Farther down the tube, where the material is no heated significantly, the mechanical properties introduced by heat treating still stands. Does using heat treated tubes reduce cracking? Hesitently, yes, heat treated tubes MAY help to reduce cracking, but cannot make significant changes to the HAZ.


So what do we do?

Post Weld Heat Treating works to relieve the HAZ. The irregular shape of the weld remains, but the brittleness of the surrounding tubes can be significantly reduced. This simple step is often overlooked because it usually requires shipping the component off, or adding machines to the shop. But it is worth it. Take a look at Odyssey's post weld heat treating and how it has brought that company (along with a better business model) to great status in BMX.

So the next time you see a company bragging about 4Q Baked, 420 Baked, or these other marketing ploys (including 41 thermal, but they actually did it right), see if there is an alternative from a company telling you something meaningful: post weld heat treatment. Luckily, more an more frames are going this direction. We can only hope to see the same from Bars, cranks, forks, etc...

Shadow Torrid V2 Cranks



Flipping through Dan's I saw the shadow Torrid cranks. Now I realize these are not new, but they are interesting. If you take a look at the patent for it, they originally designed the crank to use a chromoly spine (4140 not specified), with an aluminum shell. I'm not sure if they ever made this in a production run, but there are a few reasons why this is not necessarily a good idea:

  • Different materials have different properties. Specifically, they have different elasticity, and different rates of thermal expansion.
  • Joining (welding) dissimilar materials is difficult. Although there are filler materials available for joining Aluminum and Steel, but they make structural sacrafices in order to get proper fusion of both materials.
  • There is no purpose in using two materials. Profile and the new Torrids show how steel is enough on its own.
Now the current version of the Torrid cranks use a 4140 spine and a 4130 shell... Again, I am not so sure this is really necessary, or even advantageous. We can't really know what their goal in using different materials is. However, we can speculate they wanted the stiffness of 4140. I assume they weld the shell to the spine along the ridge, which would stiffen the whole structure by making virtually the whole crank a heat affected zone. Well they could post weld heat treat (anneal), as all welded components should be, but I would assume they would market that as well.

After running a few circles, where are we? Boasting that it is patented, the use of two parts, and two materials, all makes me weary this is mostly just marketing. Does that mean they are crap and will break? No, not at all. But if we are to aim for the highest strength to weight ratio, this design is probably not the way to go.

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Flash Welded Rims

I was browsing through Eclat's site when I saw their rims were Flash welded

It'd be interesting to see how other rims are welded. Perhaps there are many other rims that use this technology. Especially since bicycle rims are noted in the TWI article.



They do also say the Bondi Rim "... features a unique wide design which spreads the impact load of harsh landings more thoroughly" I don't know about that. They're also lower profile, which would reduce stiffness radially. I would expect this rim can take a hit axially (i.e. Whips, spins, etc)

Note: TWI is a very reputable resource for info on welding. We used them for some research on titanium welding.